Old-Fashioned Holiday Cookies

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure policy here. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

When you come from a place where there are basically two seasons, “summer” and “less summer,” it can be hard to get into the Christmas spirit. When it’s November and 81 degrees outside, you feel a little silly busting out the hot cocoa, roasting chestnuts over a open fire, and rocking that trendy winter coat. So you find yourself relying on other social cues–When does the neighbor put his lights up? When do the candy canes go on sale?–to help get you in a holiday mood.

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Fortunately, in Boston I’ve found it’s much easier to know when the Holidays are upon us. When the water in your freshly-washed hair starts to freeze on your walk to work (true story), it’s Christmas time!

So in celebration, I thought I would share with you my favorite Holiday cookie recipe. But first, a little background.

When my grandfather was young, he used to mow the lawn for a sweet little old lady that would bake him Christmas cookies every year. Every year these cookies were so good he would ask her for the recipe. It was a family secret, she said. It had been in her family since they had come over on the Mayflower, she said, and it couldn’t possibly be given out. Every year he asked, and every year she said no.

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Years later, before she passed away, this little old lady gave my grandfather two things: a single barrel shotgun her father carried with him as he rode in a covered wagon to Arizona, and this secret cookie recipe.

THE RECIPE

  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1 cup Crisco
  • 2 unbeaten eggs
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • 1 tsp. vanilla
  • 2 tsp. baking soda
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 6 cups flour
Get my 5 Sanity-Saving Secrets for Gentle Moms and get more done with less yelling

DIRECTIONS

Cream together sugar, crisco, eggs, and sour cream. Mix together your flour, sugar, soda and salt before adding it to your wet mix.

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Of course, the original recipe did not call for Crisco or sour cream as we know it. Lard or butter was probably used in place of Crisco. And rather than sour cream, the original recipe called for “clabber” cream, which is made by letting unpasteurized milk stand until the cream rises to the top, leaving the milk below it thicker and slightly sour, just like sour cream. I thought that was interesting. Back to the recipe–which, by the way, makes about 5 or 6 dozen cookies. I usually make a half batch.

When your dough starts to get flakey (like below), its time to toss the wooden spoon and mix it together with your hands until you have a nice big ball of dough and all the flour is mixed in.

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Roll out your cookies on a flour surface until your dough is about 1/4″ thick. You’re going to obviously want to flour your rolling pin, and maybe even your cookie cutters.

In the past I  would always make a huge floury mess when I made these, so I tried rolling them out on parchment paper and that works wonderfully. It is kind of hard to start out the rolling because the paper wants to move around, but you could tape it down or something. Put it this way: I liked it better than having to clean off a mess of residual dough and flour when I finished.

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Bake your cookies at 400 degrees F for just about 5 minutes, maybe 6. The bottom of your cookie shouldn’t be much darker than this:

Old Fashioned Holiday Cookies | www.EssentiallyEclectic.com | A simple, delicious old fashioned roll out holiday cookie recipe paired with buttercream frosting. Fun to make, and great to leave out for Santa!

Once these have cooled, I make a simple buttercream frosting using butter, powered sugar, milk, vanilla extract, and food coloring, and I decorate accordingly!

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

As it turns out, and as I’m sure you’ve guessed, this recipe is not actually a secret (although I’m sure my family would swear otherwise!). And although I can’t guarantee it actually came over on the Mayflower, can I say with a pretty high degree of certainty that these cookies are mighty delicious!

So fear not, Friends! No secrets were harmed in the posting of this recipe :)

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy

Old-Fashioned Roll Out Holiday Cookies

  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1 cup Crisco
  • 2 unbeaten eggs
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • 1 tsp . vanilla
  • 2 tsp . baking soda
  • 1 tsp . salt
  • 6 cups flour
  1. Cream together sugar, crisco, eggs, and sour cream.
  2. Mix together your flour, sugar, soda and salt before adding it to your wet mix.
  3. When your dough starts to get flakey, knead the dough until it is thoroughly mixed.
  4. Roll out your cookies on a flour surface until your dough is about 1/4″ thick and cut with a cookie cutter.
  5. Bake at 400 F for 5 minutes or until cookie bottoms are a light golden.

Happy Holidays, and I hope you enjoy these old fashioned roll out holiday cookies!

Love,
Gabby

Our family legend says the recipe for these old-fashioned holiday cookies came off the Mayflower. You'll love making these cookies a Christmas tradition! | Holiday cookie recipe | Buttercream icing cookies | Christmas cookie recipe | Christmas cookies | Cookies for Santa | Mom Makes Joy